TIVO is the most well known basic PVR and they got there by licensing the service to other vendors in the field ... mainly Sony and Philips.

Are you planning to replace your VCR with a PVR?

Rob Williams

Are you planning to replace your VCR with a PVR?
By Rob Williams

TIVO is the most well known basic PVR and they got there by licensing the service to other vendors in the field ... mainly Sony and Philips.

Here's a look at some alternatives to using a VCR to record TV programs.  The common name for these units is PVR (personal video recorder). To help you decide which is best for you ... here are a few things to look into:

  1. Is there a good TV listing service for your area for the product and for your broadcast method, off the air, cablevision digital cable or satellite.
  2. What is the recording quality and how much time can be recorded on the unit.
  3. Are the outputs of the unit compatible with your TV ... i.e. RCA output, S-Video, DVI or digital outputs for my stereo?
  4. Is there a remote for this unit that will meet your needs?

Here is a rundown on some of the systems. 

A basic PVR only does one function but does it well with ease of use as a priority. TIVO is the most well known basic PVR and they got there by licensing the service to other vendors in the field ... mainly Sony and Philips. The interface is simple and it remembers your watching and recording habits. One drawback is the monthly subscription fee $12.95 (or you can pay for a lifetime - $299.00). So far the service is only available in the U.S. market. 

Then there are many others have joined in on the success and added this function into satellite receivers and even DVD players.  You can also connect multiple units together with the $99.00 home media option. 

ReplayTV is another option with a more modest subscription fee of $11.88 per year after the 3 year initial subscription is up. These operate the same way as TIVO ... you can record, pause and skip commercials. There are also network enabled units so you can watch shows that were recorded on other units.


Gemstar ... TV Guide's interactive program guide ... is marketed as TV Guide On Screen in North America, G-Guide in Japan and Guide Plus+ in Europe. Some of the PVR's use this listing service which is a no fee system. This is the same company that licensed the VCR+ programming interface for your VCR. The advantage of using boxes which use this programming is that it is no fee system. These systems are being licensed by a lot of consumer products from Panasonic, Sharp and Samsung.

For a computer based PVR you can buy a new computer running Microsoft Windows XP Media Centre 2004 which is an upgrade on the original version which is OEM's on only certain machines. The programming guide system on this is a free system and Microsoft has improved on the original system. There are many companies that make these systems, some that add on functionality to a regular pc or others that have made a custom box that integrates into your home entertainment room such as the Touch Systems or the ZT group system. These machines are using computer cases made by Shuttle that are small compact and very quiet. Some of the different systems are at Microsoft's site. Another good site for information on these is the green button (refers to the MCE remote).

Or ... you could hook up a computer to your TV and with a TV tuner card from ATI or Hauppauge ... make your own PVR using a 3rd party software product such as Snapstream. And integrate them into a small form factor case as from Shuttle

With ATI's All-IN-WONDER and TV Wonder cards you are able to use the TV-ON-DEMAND and the Gemstar GUIDEPLUS + programming guide for free ... and it works in the USA and Canada. Plus you can get a great remote that uses RF (radio frequency) so it will work a long distance from your computer. I have used this system on a computer that I have connected to my TV and I really like the setup. Plus the Guide layout listings are top notch.

The Hauppauge PVR products come with a TV tuner card as well as a remote and use of The Electronic Program Guides - TitanTV.com in the U.S., TV.de in Europe and iEPG in Japan. These are Internet based free program guides which work with WinTV-PVR to help schedule your TV recordings.

Lastly ... you can buy a system comprised of a small PC connected to the TV as an entertainment system.  The product from Oneboxmc.com integrates this into one nice looking package.

I'm sure there are plenty of other options out there that I haven't mentioned here ... but one thing is certain ... we're only at the beginning of this trend and PVR's are here to stay.

The content & opinions in this article are the author’s and do not necessarily represent the views of HomeToys

Comments (0)

This post does not have any comments. Be the first to leave a comment below.

Post A Comment

You must be logged in before you can post a comment. Login now.

Featured Product

ELK Products -C1M1 Dual-Path Alarm Communicators with Remote Services

ELK Products -C1M1 Dual-Path Alarm Communicators with Remote Services

C1M1 offers a truly significant reduction in transmission time in comparison to other communicators that rely on dial capture or data bus decoding. This can result in quicker response time to emergency situations which could save lives and assets. By providing both IP and cellular pathways, C1M1 provides the reliability installers are looking for in an alarm communicator. C1M1 eliminates port forwarding and extra fees for remote access. Installers can remotely upload/download programming changes to M1 controls over IP or cellular using ElkRP2. Consumers can control the M1 remotely via the free ElkLink mobile app and web portal, as well as eKeypad and M1 Touch Pro apps. Other IP-based software and interface partners can connect to the M1 control over the local network through C1M1. C1M1 also provides email/text notifications for arm, disarm, and alarm events. ELK-C1M14GSM supports GSM (AT&T/T-Mobile) networks and ELK-C1M1CDMA supports CDMA (Verizon) networks.